The effect of newspaper reporting on Covid19 vaccine hesitancy: a randomized controlled trial

How to cite

Rinaldi, Anna. 2022. "The effect of newspaper reporting on Covid19 vaccine hesitancy: a randomized controlled trial." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010196. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10196-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Anna Rinaldi*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010196
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10196-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2021-05-05 – 2021-06-21
Countries
France (), Italy ()
JEL codes
D91, D81
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10196

Abstract

1,068 people were surveyed in France and Italy to inquire about individual potential acceptance, focusing on time preferences, in a risk-return framework: having the vaccination today, in a month, and in 3 months; perceived risks of vaccination and COVID-19; and expected benefit of the vaccine.
A randomized controlled trial was conducted to understand how everyday stimuli, such as fact-based news about vaccines, impact on audience acceptance of vaccination. The main experiment involved two groups of participants and two different articles about vaccine-related thrombosis taken from two Italian newspapers. One article used a more abstract description and language, and the other used a more anecdotical description and concrete language; each group read only one of these articles. Two other groups were assigned categorization tasks; one was asked to complete a concrete categorization task and the other an abstract categorization task.
All the participants were administered the DOSPERT 2006 risk elicitation questionnaire in health domain to acquire information about personal risk attitude.

Intervention

The main treatment involved two groups of participants and two different articles about vaccine-related thrombosis taken from two Italian newspapers. One article used a more abstract descriptive style and language, while the other used a more anecdotical style and concrete language: each group read only one of these articles. The articles were taken from two Italian newspapers that differ greatly in their journalistic styles and audiences. Both articles are the same length and describe an episode of vaccine-related thrombosis. The abstract text uses a more formal and impersonal language, reporting more scientific considerations; the concrete text uses a more familiar and emotional style and provides a more anecdotical description of the case.
Texts were also weighted according to a concreteness semantic vocabulary, controlling for the mean of the total words contained in the articles (concreteness index = 3.54 for concrete text vs. 2.66 for abstract text; the difference is significant: t-test alpha = 0.05).
Given that the two newspaper texts differ manifestly in their level of abstraction, it was decided to cross-control for the participants’ mindsets in order to understand whether this could be a key element influencing vaccination decisions.
For this reason, two other groups (n=238 in total) were assigned categorization tasks; one was asked to complete a concrete categorization task and the other an abstract categorization.
The control group only answered questionnaires. Questionnaire inquires about individual potential acceptance, focusing on time preferences, in a risk-return framework: getting the jab today, in a month, and in 3 months; perceived risks of vaccination and COVID-19; and expected benefit of the vaccine.
All questionnaires included also DOSPERT questionnaire in health domain.

Experimental design

The RCT is designed in this way: in 2 similar nations, in Italy and France, 1,068 individuals divided as follow:
- intervention (a) reading of the abstract text about vaccine related thrombosis
- intervention (b) reading of the abstract text about vaccine related thrombosis
- intervention (c) performing categories task
- intervention (d) performing example task

Simple randomization

Experiment was conducted via Qualtrics.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Unvaccinated individuals
Clusters
individuals in 2 nations Italy and France
Observations
1,068 unvaccinated individuals
Arms
France (538) - abstract text (153) - concrete text (164) - abstract task (55), concrete task (56) - control (110) Italy (530) - abstract text (155) - concrete text (163) - abstract task (54), concrete task (55) - control (103)
Primary outcomes
revealed vaccine preferences in a dynamic perspective number of individuals who want to receive vaccine

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords