Digitizing Bureaucracy

How to cite

Annan, Francis; Gupta, Apoorv. 2022. "Digitizing Bureaucracy." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010190. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10190-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Francis Annan* , Apoorv Gupta

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010190
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10190-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-10-07 – 2024-02-29
Countries
Ghana ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10190

Abstract

We experimentally study the impact of digitizing bureaucratic decision-making on performance of small- and medium-sized firms (SMEs) in Ghana. State and local governments often contract out development projects to SMEs – an important environment where fast-digital technology that meaningfully facilitates bureaucratic decision-making on projects will not only improve government’s capacity, but also have the potential to reduce frictions via timely processing and payments for projects to SMEs, with significant implications for increased firm productivity and project outcomes. We partner with the Ministry of Local Government and its technology solutions provider, Casantey Business Solutions Group Ltd., to design and evaluate the impact of a cloud-based solution technology that reduces bureaucratic bottlenecks and uniquely features two structural components (i) addresses coordination failures vs (ii) addresses payment failures. We randomly assign a large pool of select firm-linked projects to the solution technology to uplift projects administration and payments, and carefully measure firm performance.
Research questions—This research seeks to answer two questions:
1. Whether digitizing bureaucratic decision-making can improve firm’s productivity and performance, and
2. How much of improvement in firm’s performance are due to coordination frictions and/or payments concerns?

Partners:
(i) Ministry of Local Government and Rural Development, Ghana; (ii) Casantey Business Solutions Group Ltd., Ghana; (iii) Ghana Statistical Services (GSS)

Intervention

The Ministry’s project and procurement office will provide the list of all live and pipeline projects. We will identify the select pool of uniquely approved and upcoming firm-linked projects, all to be completed within a year (N=600+). The select projects or firms will be randomly assigned to 1 control and 2 treatment groups

Experimental design

We will randomly assign 1/3rd of the projects as Control projects (Status Quo: no digitization), 1/3rd as Treatment 1 projects (fully-digitize: apply the cloud-based solution technology to address both coordination and payment issues in the projects administration), and 1/3rd as Treatment 2 projects (partially-digitize: apply the cloud-based solution technology to address only coordination issues in the projects administration).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by a computer
Randomization unit
Randomization of treatments is at the project- or firm-level and will ensure balance on both project and firm characteristics. using baseline information gathered on the projects and firms. We will stratify by (i) project class (central vs local) and (ii) firm size (small vs large), yielding 4 unique strata, and all misfits will be resolved and randomly assigned.
Clusters
Target sample is 600+ approved and upcoming firm-linked projects, all such projects to be completed within a year
Observations
N/A
Arms
200+ firm-linked projects per experimental arm (totaling 3 x 200+ = 600+ firm-linked projects)
Primary outcomes
1ST STAGE OUTCOMES: (i) Administrative data: processing delayed/not, payment delayed/not; speed of processing project certificates and payments; total value of payments made; auxiliary statistics: project status (completed on time/ongoing/abandoned), number of handling officers, number of steps, etc. (ii) Business survey data: total payments received for this ended project; experienced any delay in processing project (and by how long); experienced any delay in payment of project (and by how long); number of new projects applied for; value of new government projects started; value of other non-government projects ongoing 2ND STAGE OUTCOMES: Business survey data: firm productivity, employment, wage bill, expenses, revenues, value of assets, profits, quality of projects
Secondary outcomes
% employees paid electronically; % suppliers paid electronically; overall digitization and IT usage of your business; bribe payments (and bribe value); satisfaction with financial wellbeing; satisfaction with mental wellbeing; satisfaction with business’s security; ability to pay workers on time; ability to pay suppliers on time; ability to pay lenders on time; ability to fulfill “all other” business obligations required on time; overall perception about public contracts/ projects administration; overall perception about the government in general; likelihood of seeking for public contracts

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords