Evaluating Interventions to Reduce Choice Errors in California's Affordable Care Act Marketplace
How to cite
Feher, Andrew. 2022. "Evaluating Interventions to Reduce Choice Errors in California's Affordable Care Act Marketplace." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010165. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10165-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 dramatically expanded the Affordable Care Act’s (ACA) subsidies, but many low-income enrollees may not know that they can switch to a more generous Cost-Sharing Reduction (CSR) Silver plan with no increase in their monthly premium. During the 2022 Open Enrollment Period in California’s ACA marketplace, we tested two interventions designed to increase CSR Silver take-up among low-income households enrolled in bronze plans. The first intervention used a behaviorally-informed letter paired with three email reminders. The second intervention automatically crosswalked eligible households from bronze to $0 CSR Silver plans with the same health insurer at the beginning of the renewal period. Amid the availability of enhanced marketplace subsidies through the end of 2025, our findings inform current health policy debates on the relative effectiveness of different approaches to improve plan choice quality for low-income households.
Intervention
The intervention was deployed in California's ACA marketplace among low-income households eligible for CSR Silver 94 coverage but enrolled in bronze plans. The intervention for those assigned to the treatment group included a behaviorally-informed letter paired with three email reminders.
Experimental design
In September 2021, we identified 9,288 CSR Silver 94-eligible households with an email address enrolled in bronze plans for the 2021 enrollment year. To understand the extent to which informational nudges – delivered via direct mail and email – could induce these enrollees in bronze plans to switch to CSR Silver plans, we used Stata to randomly assign 30 percent of households to a control group (n = 2,777) and the remaining 70 percent to a letter and email treatment group (n = 6,511). Beyond the required renewal notice, households in the control group did not receive any messages in October 2021, but from November to January they received the standard messages that Covered California sends to renewing consumers during open enrollment, which encourage members to shop and compare plans and provide information on the differences between metal tiers but do not make explicit recommendations. Households in the treatment group received the required renewal notice and were assigned to receive a CSR-specific letter in mid-October followed by three email reminders sent in November and December 2021. These outreach materials included out-of-pocket savings when a consumer visits the doctor or fills a prescription, a screenshot of what the CSR Silver plan would look like when they entered the shopping portal, peer comparison language that noted 9 out of 10 consumers like them choose CSR Silver plans and different ways to switch plans (e.g. self-serving or working with an enrollment assister). Households that had indicated a written language preference of Spanish received outreach in Spanish; all other consumers received outreach in English.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.