Moral Preference of Firms - Privatization of Sanctions

How to cite

thesmar, david; Zingales, Luigi; Hart, Oliver. 2022. "Moral Preference of Firms - Privatization of Sanctions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010156. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10156-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

david thesmar* , Luigi Zingales , Oliver Hart

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010156
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10156-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-05-19 – 2022-06-28
Countries
United States of America ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10156

Abstract

Our goal is to understand how firm stakeholders want a firm to behave when it is in a position to sanction a sovereign. do they think this is not the company's role to do this? do they think the company should participate to the sanction? how much of their own wealth are they willing to sacrifice for this? do they care about impact?

We conduct a survey on some 3000 US participants, using a survey firm.

We ask how participants would behave as stakeholders of a hypothetical firm. This firm has sizable operations in Russia. In the midst of the war with Ukraine, this hypothetical firm decides to not exit from Russia. Participants are asked whether they are willing to punish the firm as stakeholders. We randomize:
- which stakeholder they are (customer, shareholder, employee). for instance, employees can quit, shareholders can sell their shares, customers can boycott
- what impact they have on the firm by punishing (stock price drops, or not; firm loses on customer, or not, etc.)
- how much it will cost, to participants, to implement this punishment.

Then, we ask how they justify their decision (impact, moral imperative, etc), and information on socio-demographics, on moral values they adhere to, political stance, etc.

Intervention

We conduct a survey on some 3000 US participants, using a survey firm.

We ask how participants would behave as stakeholders of a hypothetical firm. This firm has sizable operations in Russia. In the midst of the war with Ukraine, this hypothetical firm decides to not exit from Russia. Participants are asked whether they are willing to punish the firm as stakeholders. We randomize:
- which stakeholder they are (customer, shareholder, employee). for instance, employees can quit, shareholders can sell their shares, customers can boycott
- what impact they have on the firm by punishing (stock price drops, or not; firm loses on customer, or not, etc.)
- how much it will cost, to participants, to implement this punishment.

Then, we ask how they justify their decision (impact, moral imperative, etc), and information on socio-demographics, on moral values they adhere to, political stance, etc.

Experimental design

We conduct a survey on some 3000 US participants, using a survey firm.

We ask how participants would behave as stakeholders of a hypothetical firm. This firm has sizable operations in Russia. In the midst of the war with Ukraine, this hypothetical firm decides to not exit from Russia. Participants are asked whether they are willing to punish the firm as stakeholders. We randomize:
- which stakeholder they are (customer, shareholder, employee). for instance, employees can quit, shareholders can sell their shares, customers can boycott
- what impact they have on the firm by punishing (stock price drops, or not; firm loses on customer, or not, etc.)
- how much it will cost, to participants, to implement this punishment.

Then, we ask how they justify their decision (impact, moral imperative, etc), and information on socio-demographics, on moral values they adhere to, political stance, etc.

Design details

Randomization method
we have 3 layers of randomization: - type of stakeholder (3 arms) - cost paid (3 arms) - impact, or not (3 arms for shareholders, 2 for customers and employees)
Randomization unit
individual participants, recruited over internet
Clusters
2915 participants
Observations
2915 particiapnts
Arms
- 3 equal sized arms for stakeholders - 3 equal sized levels of costs - 2 equal sized impact treatments (3 for shareholders)
Primary outcomes
what makes people willing to support private sanctions taken by companies? (more exactly in our setting: what makes people willing to punish the absence of sanctions?)
Secondary outcomes
once people have answered this question, we ask them further questions to understand their motivations. we also ask questions about moral and political values.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords