Transforming Brick Manufacturing in Bangladesh to Promote Clean Air and Better Health

How to cite

Luby, Stephen; Miller, Grant; Brooks, Nina. 2022. "Transforming Brick Manufacturing in Bangladesh to Promote Clean Air and Better Health." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010127. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10127-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Stephen Luby* , Grant Miller , Nina Brooks

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010127
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10127-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-09-26 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10127

Abstract

Across South Asia, the brick manufacturing industry is dominated by inefficient, coal-burning kilns. Brick kilns are one of the largest emitters in the region. In Bangladesh, kilns contribute 17% of the country’s annual CO2 emissions and 11% of PM2.5. The pollution released by these kilns worsens local air quality, health and agricultural productivity, and global climate. Reducing these emissions could generate large social benefits. A properly constructed and operated zigzag kiln can reduce black carbon by 41%, CO2 by 21%, and PM2.5 by 80% – and strikingly, also increase kiln profitability. Yet the vast majority are incorrectly constructed and operated. Our preliminary work found that lack of knowledge regarding proper construction and operation and inattention to worker incentives undermine kiln operation. We propose a randomized intervention among kiln owners in Bangladesh that relaxes these barriers to improve kiln performance, reduce air pollution, and lower greenhouse gas emissions.

Intervention

A properly constructed and operated zig zag kiln can reduce black carbon by 41%, CO2 by 21%, and PM2.5 by 80%. However, most conversions to zig zag kilns in Bangladesh have been poorly implemented. Consequently, the new zig zag kiln appear to be just as polluting as the older style they replaced. Our study of kiln owners suggests a puzzle: a correctly built and operated zig zag kiln can increase kiln profits, yet these gains are not realized by owners with poorly constructed and operated kilns. Our preliminary work suggests two primary barriers to effective implementation: 1) lack of knowledge of the specific interventions and their true economic return and 2) inattention to the incentives of workers whose cooperation is crucial to running an efficient kiln.
We will address these barriers through a randomized intervention that provides:
1) extensive information, training, and technical support on low-cost improvements
2) information and encouragement to kiln owners to adopt strategies that incentivize workers to adopt the new practices.

Experimental design

We hypothesize that by addressing the most important barriers to improved kiln operation, we can improve efficiency of kiln operation and reduce air pollution and GHG emitted in the short term. A growing body of economics literature addresses poor management in low-income countries; however the evidence remains mixed on the best strategies to improve management and why owners do not themselves invest in these profit-enhancing strategies. Entrepreneurship and business management trainings targeted toward microfinance beneficiaries have not increased longer-term profit or income, perhaps because they were not sufficiently intensive, whereas an intensive but costly management consulting intervention among Indian textile firms substantially increased productivity. Perhaps most closely related to our setting, a cost-saving technology delivered to soccer ball factories in Pakistan initially failed due to misaligned incentives between owners and workers.

Drawing on this evidence and our team’s experience in India and Bangladesh, we will deliver a randomized intervention that provides intensive training and technical support, information and encouragement to kiln owners to incentivize workers to adopt the new practices, and testimonials from pilot kiln owners who adopted these practices and saw increases in profits. We will have two experimental arms: 1) technical knowledge and training (technical arm) and 2) technical knowledge and training + worker incentives (incentive arm). Kilns assigned to both arms will receive information, training, and encouragement to adopt a suite of technical and operational improvements including improved firing practices, improved brick setting, increased insulation, and good bookkeeping. Trainings will highlight the financial benefits of these improvements and include live participation from owners who adopted them during our pilot, to directly address owners’ uncertainty of economic returns. This will be delivered in the form of an initial “classroom” training, a series of on-kiln trainings targeting specific operational components, and technical support available throughout the firing season. Kilns in the incentive arm will receive the technical training plus additional information and recommendations to encourage use of targeted worker incentives. The recommendations, which include a mix of financial and non-financial mechanisms, are informed by the economics literature, the experience of Indian kiln owners, results from our pilot, and testimonials from owners who participated in our pilot study.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
firm level (brick kiln)
Clusters
Not applicable
Observations
300 brick kilns + 1800 workers
Arms
100 kilns per arm (control, technical, incentive); 600 workers per arm (with 6 workers from each kiln across different job categories).
Primary outcomes
Primary outcomes will include carbon monoxide/carbon dioxide ratio (a measure of combustion efficiency measured by placing a sensor into the flu gas), specific energy consumption (the energy used in MJ for firing 1 kg of brick) and proportion of Class 1 bricks produced. We will track coal usage and sample coal to test for carbon content, and then apply the IPCC’s methodology to estimate tons of CO2 abated due to the intervention by converting specific energy consumption to CO2. Secondary outcomes include additional measures of brick production and earnings, as well as measures of working conditions and whether any type of worker incentives were adopted.
Sponsors
Name: Stanford Impact Labs Location: Stanford, California, USA Url: https://impact.stanford.edu/ Name: J-PAL King Climate Action Initiative Location: Cambridge, MA, USA Url: https://www.povertyactionlab.org
Partners
Name: icddr,b Partner_type: ngo Url: https://www.icddrb.org Name: Greentech Knowledge Solutions Partner_type: private_company Url: https://www.gkspl.in Name: Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology Partner_type: government Url: https://www.buet.ac.bd/web/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords