Health and Inequality; Health Behavior; Health Insurance, Public and Private; Welfare Economics; Equity, Justice, Inequality, and Other Normative Criteria and Measurement;
European welfare states are being challenged by persisting health inequalities. Against this background, this study will examine the relation between health attribution and health policy preferences. The purpose is twofold. First, we aim to unravel how citizens attribute health inequalities and what the individual-level predictors of health inequality attribution are. Second, we aim to gain a better understanding of how health attribution shapes health policy preferences. To this end, the study draws on a survey experiment and observational data, to be fielded among the German population. The module is part of a large-N opinion survey on inequality and social mobility conducted by the University of Konstanz.
Intervention
A survey module with an embedded survey experiment is designed. To examine how citizens attribute responsibility for health and health care costs, survey vignettes are used to describe a fictive person in need of medical treatment. The vignettes provide a causal cue on the health problems of the fictive person. In total, respondents are presented two different scenarios of the in total 36 unique scenarios included in the experiment. The characteristics in each vignette are randomly assigned. Hereby, heterogeneity in the effects of individual dimensions will be analysed.
Experimental design
The survey vignettes differ along three dimensions: the income, the health problem, and a cue about the cause of the health problem. A 3*3*4 experimental research design is implemented, resulting in 36 unique combinations. Each vignette consists of four pieces of information: (1) An introduction sentence, (2) a randomization of the income, (3) a randomization of the health problem, (4) a randomization of the causal cue of the health problem.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization by computer.
Randomization unit
Randomisation at the individual level.
Clusters
6000 individuals.
Observations
6000 individuals.
Arms
A minimum of 330 observations per unique vignette.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes of interest are respondents' attribution of responsibility of (1) health outcomes and (2) health care costs.
(1) Question wording:
"Some people might think that this person is to blame for his own health problems. Others might think that this person is not to blame at all.
What is your spontaneous impression about it?"
Answer categories:
11-point
0 = This person is not at all to blame
10 = This person is completely to blame
(2) Question wording:
"Some people feel that in a fair society, this person should pay for the entire cost of his medical treatment. Others think that in a fair society, all treatment costs of this person should be covered by the society, through taxes or insurance contributions. What is your opinion?"
Answer categories:
11-point
0 = Society should pay all the costs
10 = The person should pay all the costs
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcomes are respondents' (1) health inequality attributions and (2) general health policy preferences.
(1)
Question wordings:
"On average, low-income Germans live 6 years shorter than high-income Germans. There are many reasons for the difference in life expectancy. What do you think is the main reason for this shorter life expectancy?"
Answer categories:
1. Because their own behavior damages their health.
2. Because of inborn characteristics (genetic or biological)
3. Because of the environmental conditions they are exposed to at work or where they live
4. Because of unequal treatment in the health care system
(2)
Question wording:
"How willing would you be to pay higher taxes to improve health care for all people in Germany?"
Answer categories:
5-point
1 - Very unwilling, 2 - Fairly unwilling, 3 - Neither willing nor unwilling, 4 - Fairly willing, 5 - Very willing
Question wording:
"Please indicate now to what extent the following things should be the responsibility of the state: ensure adequate health care for the sick"
Answer categories:
11-point
0 = The state should not be responsible at all
10 = The state should be entirely responsible
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.