Perceived Control and Motivated Cognition about Air Pollution.

How to cite

Soldà, Alice; Balietti, Anca; Eymess, Tillmann; Budjan, Angelika. 2022. "Perceived Control and Motivated Cognition about Air Pollution.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010083. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10083-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Alice Soldà* , Anca Balietti , Tillmann Eymess , Angelika Budjan

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010083
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10083-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-10-01 – 2022-12-01
Countries
Belgium ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10083

Abstract

Despite easily accessible information about the negative health externalities of environmental pollution, households' marginal willingness to pay for environmental quality is surprisingly low. In light of this puzzle, we design a large-scale online experiment to better understand individuals' attitudes towards air pollution-related information. We focus on two mechanisms: information avoidance and memory retention. In addition, we test whether an increase in perceived control over one's own health outcomes reduces failures to attend to information. To do so, participants in the experiment are asked whether they would like to acquire information about the number of life-years lost in their home region due to air pollution. Before participants make their decision, we exogenously increase participants' perceived control over the negative effect of air pollution on their own health, in half of the sample. After indicating their choice, participants either receive information about the number of life-years lost in their county or no information at all, based on a random draw. Participants who do receive information are then asked to recall the number of life-years lost in their county (i) shortly after receiving it and (ii) after two weeks.

Experimental design

To investigate how perceived control affects (i) information avoidance and (ii) memory retention, we design an experiment in which we manipulate the level of perceived control (Baseline vs. High Perceived Control).

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization of the allocation of participants to treatments will be done by the experimental program. We use the Latin square method.
Randomization unit
The treatments are randomized at the individual level.
Clusters
2000 individuals from California (USA) + 1000 individuals from across India.
Observations
2000 individuals from California (USA) + 1000 individuals from across India.
Arms
Part 1 USA: 1000 individuals in the control group, 1000 individuals in the high perceived control treatment. All 2000 individuals will be asked to choose whether or not to receive information about the number of life years lost in their home district. Their choice will be implemented with 60% probability. Part 1 India: 750 individuals in the control group, 750 individuals in the high perceived control treatment. All 1500 individuals will be asked to choose whether or not to receive information about the number of life years lost in their home district. Their choice will be implemented with 60% probability. In Part 2 (the follow up after 2 weeks), all participants that received information about the number of life years lost in their county/district will be invited.
Primary outcomes
a) Information Acquisition - A dummy variable indicating whether participants choose to receive information on the number of life years lost from air pollution in their home region or not. b) Information Recall - A dummy variable indicating whether participants remember the exact number of life years lost immediately after receiving the information. - A dummy variable indicating whether participants remember the number of life years lost from air pollution in their home region within half a year of the correct answer, immediately after receiving the information. - A dummy variable indicating whether participants remembered the exact number of life years lost from air pollution in their home region two weeks after receiving the information. - A dummy variable indicating whether participants remembered the number of life years lost from air pollution in their home region within half a year of the correct answer, two weeks after receiving the information. - The accuracy of participants' recall shortly after receiving the information measured as the difference between participants' recall of the number of life years lost in their home region and the actual number of life years lost in their home region. - The accuracy of participants' recall two weeks after receiving the information measured as the difference between participants' recall of the number of life years lost in their home region and the actual number of life years lost in their home region. c) Self-reported perceived control - Participants' reported perceived control measured both as (i) their score on the 6 general perceived control items and (ii) their answer to the single perceived control item from Tropes et al. (2003).
Secondary outcomes
See Experiment design document.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords