Gender norms, couples' labor supply decisions, and flexibility in working conditions in Colombia
How to cite
Salas, Luz Magdalena; Diaz, Ana Maria; Boltz, Marie. 2022. "Gender norms, couples' labor supply decisions, and flexibility in working conditions in Colombia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010082. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10082-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We aim to study how gender norms – tasks sharing, and gender roles - affect intra-household decisions about labor market participation and the likelihood for each spouse to accept flexible work arrangements. We will first conduct a baseline survey representative for cohabiting couples in Bogotá to elicit gender norms concerning labor market participation and willingness to accept flexible jobs. The objective is to identify whether Colombia is a context of pluralistic ignorance, namely whether Colombians hold an opinion, but mistakenly believe that others hold the opposite opinion. As a result, individuals behave in ways that are incongruent with their personal opinions and congruent, instead with what they mistakenly believe to be the norm. Contingent on finding this evidence, in a second step, we will conduct a discrete choice experiment among couples where we will measure how the willingness to work and the propensity to accept flexible work will vary by gender and according to experimental variations: (i) the presence of the other spouse when making one’s choices, (ii) providing or not the information about what is the average preferences of other couples from the same neighborhood about female labor force participation and male and female willingness to accept a flexible job. This project will make an original contribution by drawing a direct link between the growing literature on the demand for flexibility at the workplace and the one on intra-family decisions.
Intervention
We aim at studying how gender norms – tasks sharing, gender roles - affect intra-household decisions about labor market participation and the likelihood for each spouse to accept flexible work-arrangements. We will first conduct a baseline survey representative for cohabiting couples in Bogotá, in order to elicit gender norms with respect to labor market participation and willingness to accept flexible jobs. The objective is to be able to identify whether Colombia is a context of pluralistic ignorance, namely whether Colombians hold an opinion, but mistakenly believe that others hold the opposite opinion. As a result, individuals behave in ways that are incongruent with their personal opinions and congruent, instead with what they mistakenly believe to be the norm. Contingent on finding this evidence, in a second step, we will conduct a discrete choice experiment among couples where we will measure how the willingness to work and the propensity to accept flexible work will vary by gender and according to experimental variations: (i) the presence of the other spouse when making one’s choices, (ii) providing or not the information about what is the average preferences of other couples from the same neighborhood about female labor force participation and male and female willingness to accept a flexible job. This project will make an original contribution by drawing a direct link between the growing literature on the demand for flexibility at the workplace and the one on intra-family decisions.
Experimental design
a. Reconstructing beliefs
The experimental sample will include couples of parents of children between 2 and 7 years of age. Participants will answer the same incentivized survey that baseline participants responded (gender norms beliefs). Then, we will randomly assign each couple to one of four experimental groups. The assignment will be stratified.
The four treatments are the following (the discrete choice experiment is presented in the next section).
T0 (no information + without the presence of the other spouse): control group. Sample: married couples. Women and men will participate in the discrete choice experiment separately, no information will be provided about population beliefs on labor gender norms.
T1 (information + without the presence of the other spouse): we will provide information about population beliefs on labor gender norms to each spouse separately – making sure that the interview takes place at the same time in two different private places. Then, each spouse will participate in the discrete choice experiment separately.
T2 (no information + with spouse presence): a sample of couples will participate in presence of the other spouse in the discrete choice experiment. The couple will not receive any information about population beliefs on labor gender norms.
T3 (information + with spouse presence): we will provide information about population beliefs on labor gender norms to the couple (both wife and husband). Then, they will participate in the discrete choice experiment in the presence of the other spouse.
b. Discrete-choice experiment on labor-supply decisions:
Our main outcomes of interests are the participants’ labor supply decisions that we will elicit by using a discrete choice experiment.
We will elicit the willingness to work under different working arrangement and the willingness to pay for more flexibility using a discrete choice experiment. Participants will be asked to consider among three employment opportunities in a hypothetical situation. Both, women and men will be asked to consider their status quo relative to two alternative options that vary in terms of flexibility and employment status and job flexibility of the couple. Using this information, we are able to contrast first and second order beliefs about gender norms with this set of preferences for labor market participation for couples.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.