Evaluating the impact of two low-cost interventions to reduce discrimination against Venezuelan migrant students in Ecuador
How to cite
Marotta, Luana; Cuadros, Cynthia Van Der Werf; Duryea, Suzanne; Drouet, Marcelo; Millan, Jaime. 2022. "Evaluating the impact of two low-cost interventions to reduce discrimination against Venezuelan migrant students in Ecuador." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010066. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10066-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study aims to provide new causal evidence on the prejudices faced by immigrant students and solutions to mitigate them. Segregation and discriminatory attitudes represent a major barrier to immigrant children integration. While teachers’ negative stereotypes can have permanent adverse consequences on children’s human capital accumulation, relatively little is known about how to reduce and prevent such biases. We focus on Ecuador, a country that has received unprecedented large inflows of Venezuelan immigrants over the past five years. Using administrative data of end-of-term exam grades as well as objective performance measures from standardized test scores, we evaluate the impact of two interventions directed to school teachers: first, a short video that reveals information on equal performance and ambitions of natives and immigrant students, second, we provide personalized feedback on own implicit biases using an Implicit Association Test. The study will constitute one of the first interventions in the region to reduce bias against immigrant students.
Intervention
We evaluate the impact of two low-cost interventions:
1. An informative video: We present a video to around half of the teachers randomly selected at the school level. Considering that perspective-taking and experiencing the emotions of a minority group might be an effective debiasing strategy (Bertrand and Duflo, 2017), the video starts by providing background information about the Venezuelan exodus focusing on the children involved and the challenges they face upon arrival. Then, we provide evidence showing that the performance of immigrant students is comparable to the one of Ecuadorians and that the future aspirations of both groups are equally high.
We measure the effect of this low-cost intervention on the end-of-term exams of the first semester.
2. IAT feedback. We invite all teachers to take an immigration IAT adjusted to measure stereotypes between Venezuelans and Ecuadorians. We randomly select a group of teachers to receive feedback on their implicit bias towards immigrant students according to their IAT score just after they complete the test. We evaluate the effect of the second intervention on the end-of term exams of the second semester. After teacher grade the second semester, we will give feedback about the IAT score to the control group.
Experimental design
In this study we will replicate the work of Alesina et.al (2018), in Italian schools, adapted for the context of Ecuador. This design seeks to answer the following questions:
1. Are teachers in Ecuador biased against immigrant Venezuelan students?
2. Can a low-cost general informative intervention help reduce the bias against immigrant students?
3. Do teachers change their behavior when they are aware of their own implicit stereotypes?
We select teachers from 700 public schools that have at least 3 Venezuelan students in their class. We then proceed in two stages:
In the first stage we randomly divide schools in two groups: treatment and control. Before the interventions start, all teachers and school directors receive an invitation to participate in a study that aims to strengthen the relationship between teachers and students. We announce that participants will have to complete two surveys. In this invitation, we do not mention anything related to immigration, discrimination or teachers’ bias. The week before the first semester exams, those participating in the study will receive via e-mail the following:
● Treatment 1: A survey that collects sociodemographic characteristics and teachers’ beliefs followed by the informative video (intervention 1).
● Control 1: The same survey as the treatment group but no video.
We will then measure the impact of the video intervention on the grades differences of the first semester exams.
The second stage focuses on the IAT treatment (intervention 2). We split randomly the treatment and control groups defined before into two groups each, ending with four arms (conditional on the number of schools that participate in the first part of the study).. After the first semester but before the second semester exams, all participants will receive a second survey with the IAT instrument.
● Treatment 1 is divided in two groups:
○ Treatment 1 (Video) + Treatment 2 (IAT feedback): Receive a survey with an IAT followed by feedback on their IAT score
○ Treatment 1 (Video) - Control 2 (No IAT feedback): Receive a survey with an IAT but no feedback is provided before the study ends.
● Control 1 is divided in two groups:
○ Control 1 (No video) + Treatment 2 (IAT feedback): Receive a survey with an IAT followed by feedback on their IAT score.
○ Control 1 (No video) + Control 2 (No IAT feedback): Receive a survey with an IAT but no feedback is provided before the study ends.
We will then measure the impact of the IAT intervention on the grades differences of the second semester exams.
At each stage, the randomization is performed at the school level rather than at the teacher level to avoid contamination between those that received the video and those who did not. Furthermore, it prevents unrest for those teachers that do not receive the IAT feedback.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.