Randomized Educational Interventions on Social Interactions and Incentives in the Classroom Environment

How to cite

Ertac, Seda. 2022. "Randomized Educational Interventions on Social Interactions and Incentives in the Classroom Environment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010058. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10058-5.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Seda Ertac*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010058
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10058-5.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-05-09 – 2027-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93; J16; I28; I24
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10058

Abstract

We design and evaluate a series of RCTs, based on the idea of creating settings with different types of social interactions among students in the educational environment. The interventions are based on designing a set of novel educational curricula on coding, and using them as a backdrop for inducing certain types of interactions. The context of coding allows us to create a learning environment that can mimic the classroom, with exogenous rules for interactions, performance, and rewards. That is, we create our own educational setting where interactions are induced in pre-determined ways within a learning/performance context. The larger RCT has three treatment arms, based on implementing three types of coding curricula that have distinct features and are hypothesized to have distinct effects. In the first arm, we implement a cooperative learning environment within the coding program, with teamwork. In the second arm, we implement a learning environment within the coding program that involves competitive elements. These arms constitute two distinct interventions that are each compared with a third arm, where we implement the same coding program but given individually. A fourth arm serves as pure control. We aim to measure the effect of the interventions on distinct sets of outcomes, including cognitive and non-cognitive skills, competitive and cooperative behavior, beliefs about oneself and others, attitudes towards outgroups (in terms of gender and refugee status), friendship networks, learning outcomes and performance at school. In addition, we use data collected during the program to explore the mechanisms and heterogeneity of treatment effects.

Intervention

Intervention 1 (Cooperation): This intervention aims to induce cooperative interactions among students through teamwork, within a novel program where children learn how to code.

Intervention 2 (Competition): This intervention induces a learning/performance environment that involves competitive elements, again within a novel coding program.

Intervention 3 (Individual Coding): In this intervention, children learn coding individually, without structured cooperative or competitive interactions/incentives.

Pure Control: This is a group of schools where no external program is implemented (the policy-relevant control group in the Turkish educational setting).

The interventions are implemented in-class, by external instructors trained extensively by the research team, in a large sample of 4th graders in public elementary schools in Istanbul, Turkey.

Experimental design

We have 35 schools in each treatment cell: competition, cooperation, and individual, and 35 in control; a total of 140 schools. In each school, we have three classrooms in the program, randomly selected out of the classrooms that satisfy pre-established criteria as regards class size and the number of refugee students. Every classroom in the same school receives the same treatment (cooperation, competition, or individual coding). Baseline data were collected from the schools in our sample in May-June 2022.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the school.
Clusters
140 schools.
Observations
The number of students officially registered in the rosters received at the time of study plan was 14512.
Arms
35 schools in coding with cooperation, 35 schools in coding with competition, 35 schools in coding-individual, 35 schools in pure control.
Primary outcomes
The larger RCT embeds three different interventions. The outcome variables hypothesized to be affected partially differ for the three different interventions. In terms of methodology, outcome variables to be collected can be grouped under the following categories: 1) Outcomes measured by incentivized behavioral tasks, 2) Outcomes measured by self-reports, 3) Outcomes measured by objective tests administered by the research team, 4) Administrative data (e.g. school grades, behavioral conduct), 5) Data coming from teacher surveys. Below are the primary outcomes associated with each intervention. Intervention 1 (Cooperation): Primary outcome measures are cooperative behavior, in-group and out-group altruism, beliefs about/attitudes toward out-groups (over gender and refugee status), friendship networks, willingness to compete and gender differences therein, classroom cohesion level, behavioral conduct at school, learning outcomes from the coding program, performance in math, behavior in groups (leadership, power). Intervention 2 (Competition): Primary outcome measures are willingness to compete and gender differences therein, beliefs about/attitudes towards out-groups, friendship networks (over gender), learning outcomes from the coding program, performance in math, gender-related behavior in groups (leadership, power). Intervention 3 (Individual Coding): Cognitive skills, algorithmic thinking, strategic thinking, performance in math, creativity, self-confidence in math, occupational/STEM aspirations, learning outcomes from the coding program. Details of these measurements, several of which will involve the design of novel behavioral tasks, are to be provided in the pre-analysis plans for each intervention.
Secondary outcomes
Data on some variables will be collected to put forward data for mechanisms for treatment effects and for heterogeneity. For the intervention with competition, these include self-confidence, social confidence, survey measures of attitudes towards and response to competition (e.g. how relaxed one is in competitive environments), and a behavioral measure of risk attitude. For the intervention on teamwork, these include self-confidence, empathy, social confidence, how well the teams interacted/worked together, and attitudes towards responsibility. The pass-through of attitudes and peer effects (e.g. on competitiveness and grit) across the different types of curricula will be studied as a separate research question, and related variables will be collected (to be described in pre-analysis plan).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords