Information Frictions in the Labor Market: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Uganda

How to cite

Bassi, Vittorio; Rasul, Imran; Nansamba, Aisha. 2016. "Information Frictions in the Labor Market: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Uganda." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001005. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1005-3.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Vittorio Bassi* , Imran Rasul , Aisha Nansamba

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001005
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1005-3.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2014-07-01 – 2018-01-01
Countries
Uganda (Country-wide)
JEL codes
J23, J24, J46, M51, D22, D82
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1005

Abstract

This project studies the labor market matching process between young workers and firms in Uganda. We focus on three core aspects of this process. First, we study the relative importance of cognitive and non-cognitive skills in determining the labor market outcomes of young workers; second, we examine whether asymmetric information on the skills of youth that first enter the labor market is a significant source of inefficiency in terms of reduced employment opportunities and mismatch; third, we study whether an intervention improving the signal to potential employers on the skills of job market entrants reduces the asymmetric information problem and limits the related inefficiencies. We carry out this analysis through a randomized control trial in the Ugandan labor market. Our intervention exogenously improves the signals employers receive about a given young worker’s non-cognitive skills, and hence is intended to reduce information asymmetries during the recruitment process. We then trace the impacts this has on worker and firm outcomes.

Intervention

The intervention has three main components: (i) Pre-screening assessments were conducted on both the cognitive and non-cognitive skills of workers about to complete a vocational training program, and interested in participating in the intervention. (ii) Upon completion of the training program, all eligible trainees were then matched to potential employers, who had expressed an interest in meeting potential job candidates. The matching process involved facilitating a job interview between the trainee and the firm. (iii) For a random subset of matches, information on the scores of trainees on their non-cognitive skills assessments was also disclosed to both the trainee and the firm during the matching process, by means of certificates.

Experimental design

The evaluation uses a Randomized Control Trial design. On the worker side, we identified trainees that were about to complete training at 15 Vocational Training Institutes (VTIs) in Uganda. Trainees were told that as part of the programme they would be matched to available employers after the end of training, and that assessments would be conducted on their cognitive and non-cognitive skills. Trainees were explicitly told that there was the possibility of their test results being disclosed to employers during the matching. Trainees that voluntarily accepted to participate were included in the research sample. Skills assessments were then collected for all interested trainees. On the firm side, interested employers were identified by conducting a census of eligible firms in 15 urban areas of Uganda.

Upon completion of the training programme, a matching intervention was carried out, whereby our trainees were introduced to our sample of potential employers. Workers and firms were randomly assigned to two experimental groups before the matching took place: for trainees in the treatment group, additional information on their non-cognitive skills was revealed to both potential employers and the trainees themselves during the matching. This was done by means of certificates reporting the score of the trainee on the non-cognitive skills assessments conducted at the VTIs. For trainees in the control group, no additional information was revealed during the matching.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer (using STATA).
Randomization unit
Treatment assignment: Individual level randomization into treatment groups was conducted on both the worker side and the firm side. So the unit of randomization is the individual worker and the individual firm. Matching assignment: Trainees in the treatment group were randomly assigned to meet firms in the treatment group. Trainees in the control group were randomly assigned to meet firms in the control group. Randomization of the matching assignments was done at the worker-firm match level.
Clusters
Worker side: 787 workers Firm side: 422 firms Match level: 1230 worker-firm matches
Observations
Worker side: 787 workers. Firm side: 422 firms. Match level: 1230 worker-firm matches
Arms
Worker side: Control group: 397 workers Treatment group: 390 workers Firm side: Control group: 211 firms Treatment group: 211 firms Match level: Control group: 614 worker-firm matches Treatment group: 616 worker-firm matches
Primary outcomes
A first set of outcomes is at the worker-firm match level, and includes: probability of the match resulting in a job offer to the matched trainee; job characteristics, such as wages, mode of payment, tasks performed, productivity and duration for all matches resulting in the trainee being hired. A second set of outcomes relates to how the intervention may have affected the behavior of firms and workers outside the matching intervention. This second set of outcomes is at the individual worker and firm level. On the worker side, outcomes include: search effort, employment outcomes, labor market expectations and beliefs about own skills. On the firm side, they include: hiring strategies, firm size, expectations about the distribution of workers in the economy.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords