When does entrepreneurship broaden scientists’ careers beyond economic impact?

How to cite

Giones, Ferran; Lichius, Kathrin; Wahl, Andreas. 2022. "When does entrepreneurship broaden scientists’ careers beyond economic impact?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010039. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10039-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ferran Giones* , Kathrin Lichius , Andreas Wahl

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010039
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10039-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-09-26 – 2023-03-03
Countries
Germany (Baden-Württemberg)
JEL codes
L26, O31, Q55, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10039

Abstract

Early-stage researchers (ESRs - PhDs and Post-docs) are repeatedly touted as an untapped source of high-potential entrepreneurship. However, most entrepreneurship initiatives have either focused on undergraduate students or on consolidated scientists (PIs and professors). We argue that attempts to translate these initiatives to engage early-stage researchers (ESRs) are missing the positive impact of entrepreneurship beyond the direct commercialization of scientific outputs.

In this experiment we aim to achieve two objectives: 1) establish and measure the effect size of a narrow view of entrepreneurship as a linear – patent-centric – science commercialization path for ESRs, and 2) identify to what extent framing the alignment between ESRs’ social identity and the framing of an entrepreneurship training intervention can increase the likelihood of a) engaging in entrepreneurial training activities, b) the adherence to such activities.

Intervention

We use two interrelated framing interventions.
1) email content manipulation, where participants receive an invitation to be informed about either a narrow or broad entrepreneurship training program.
2) matching intervention, an invitation (also via email) to take part in an entrepreneurship training offer that matches (or not) the entrepreneurial identity of the subject.

Experimental design

1) email content manipulation, part of the subjects (stratified randomization - by department/institute) receive information that describes the entrepreneurship training program information as the beginning of a journey towards commercialization of science (business as usual), and the other subjects receive information that describes the program as a career enabler (treatment), with a broad understanding of entrepreneurship including societal and economic impact. We will be distributing the email to the sample, tracking their response (opt-in), considering if they received a broad or narrow message. For those participants that opt-in, we will send a questionnaire to identify their entrepreneurial identity (Sieger et al. 2016 JBV), their views on entrepreneurship orientation (adapting Lam 2011 RP), and essential descriptive data of the individual. This will be used in the second experiment.
2) matching intervention, part of the subjects will receive a training offer with framing and content that matches their entrepreneurial identity (narrow - economic focus / broad - career and societal impact), and part of the subjects will receive a non-matching offer. For this we will be using the survey data to characterize the subjects as aligned with a narrow - economic impact - view of entrepreneurship in science, or those with a broader entrepreneurial identity. We will be randomizing the matching non-matching to ensure that about 70% get a matching offer and 30% get a non-matching offer. We will then follow the actual enrollment in the program (yes / no), and their adherence: complete more than 60% of the suggested workshops or activities (4-5 activities in each of the offers) in the following 6 months.

Design details

Randomization method
Initial randomization by computer, 50%. Matching randomization 70/30% also by computer.
Randomization unit
Randomization (stratified) planned by institute (group-level cluster) in the first sub-experiment. Randomized at individual (cluster by identity profile) level for the second sub-experiment, matching or non-matching offer.
Clusters
150 institutes
Observations
1800 early-stage researchers, including phds and postdocs.
Arms
Balanced 50% of the planned number of participants (max. 900) in each arm for the email intervention. Unbalanced (70%/30%) for the matching (max. 1260) vs non-matching (max. 540) randomization training offer.
Primary outcomes
Uptake in an entrepreneurship training program aimed at early-stage researchers. We want to understand the effect size of an alternative framing for the intention to participate or interest, and then also understand the uptake to the program depending on a matching or non-matching offer.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords