The impact of new product introduction on attitudes towards finance

How to cite

Paaso, Mikael; Okat, Deniz; Pursiainen, Vesa; Mugabe, George. 2022. "The impact of new product introduction on attitudes towards finance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010032. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10032-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Mikael Paaso* , Deniz Okat , Vesa Pursiainen , George Mugabe

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010032
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10032-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-10-28 – 2023-12-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D14, G41, G51
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10032

Abstract

In this project, we study the impact of being introduced to mobile banking on attitudes towards other financial services. Our hypothesis is that being introduced to a new financial product can act as a "gateway" that lowers barriers (such as a lack of trust) that have previously slowed adoption of formal financial products. We therefore conduct an RCT in which people are randomly assigned to receive a cash grant, a transfer to a mobile banking account (which they will have to create) or a transfer to a mobile banking account and incentives to save using the account. We then survey these people regularly to track their attitudes towards and use of other financial products, such as loans, formal non-mobile banking and informal savings groups.

Our hypothesis, based on pre-interviews with target groups, is that active usage of mobile banking would encourage using of other formal financial products. While everyone in our sample has a physical bank account by design, these tend to be perceived as having limited utility other than a secure store of money and way to pay tuition fees. Being encouraged to use a low-cost and convenient bank account (that pays interest) which also enables easier access to borrowing could plausibly affect attitudes towards use of these products.

The prior literature has documented that being exposed to a new financial product changes people's attitudes towards that product. For instance, Bachas et al (2021) find that being introduced to debit cards leads to higher trust in the bank that issued the card and Mehrotra, Somville and Vandevalle (2021) find that repeat interactions with a banker increase trust in the banker and other bankers. There is also some evidence that being introduced to a simple bank account (and a financial literacy training program) can increase trust in banks (Horn et al. 2021) and that being introduced to a new fintech product increases stock market participation (Hong, Lu and Pan, 2021). However, Herrerias and Alvarez (2022) do not find any association between having financial product (introduced by a third party) and financial behavior.

Note: Earlier versions of this proposal involved introducing people to mobile money instead of mobile banking. After pre-interviews, we concluded that the government of Rwanda's efforts to promote mobile money during the COVID-19 pandemic and associated lockdowns had lifted usage rates among our sample so high that we would be unable to shift attitudes towards them. However, mobile money is still (based on our pre-interviews) seen as a mainly transactional device / short-term medium for holding cash. We hope that introducing a bank account that pays interest and unlocks access to loans will be perceived as sufficiently different.

Intervention

We will give cash grants to all subjects, with some people receiving the grant in cash and others in the form of a transfer to a mobile bank account. The mobile banking arm will further be randomized into an "incentivized usage" arm in which participants are offered cash incentives to provide evidence of saving in the bank account.

Experimental design

We will randomize subjects into three treatment arms.

Design details

Randomization method
Cluster randomization, pre-assigned by computer. Randomization will not be true randomization in the sense that we will intervene (before even seeing the subjects and before collecting any data) if any treatment arm has significantly more participants than expected.
Randomization unit
Cluster randomization into experimental sessions level. We are conducting the experiment on two separate sites but will randomize within each site.
Clusters
12 experimental sessions (6 on each campus). Experimental sessions are not equally sized.
Observations
C. 700 (target - depends on success in recruitment)
Arms
c. 233 subjects (4 clusters) receive cash, 233 subjects receive mobile bank accounts without incentive to save, 233 subjects receive mobile bank + incentive to save
Primary outcomes
- Preferred way to save - Attitude towards borrowing - Perceived convenience and cost of, and trust in, various financial products (informal savings groups, traditional bank account, mobile money)
Secondary outcomes
(Change in) Usage of formal financial products (savings account, mobile money, micro-insurance) Risk preferences Trust in other people Attitude towards sharing financial resources

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords