Community Driven Development in Sierra Leone

How to cite

Glennerster, Rachel; Miguel, Edward; Casey, Katherine. 2016. "Community Driven Development in Sierra Leone." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001000. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1000-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Rachel Glennerster* , Edward Miguel , Katherine Casey

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001000
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1000-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2005-10-10 – 2012-09-07
Countries
Sierra Leone (Africa)
JEL codes
F35, H41, O4
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1000

Abstract

Despite their importance, there is limited evidence on how institutions can be strengthened. Evaluating the effects of specific reforms is complicated by the lack of exogenous variation in institutions, the difficulty of measuring institutional performance, and the temptation to ‘‘cherry pick’’ estimates from among the large number of indicators required to capture this multifaceted subject. We evaluate one attempt to make local institutions more democratic and egalitarian by imposing participation requirements for marginalized groups (including women) and test for learning-by-doing effects. We exploit the random assignment of a governance program in Sierra Leone, develop innovative real-world outcome measures, and use a pre-analysis plan (PAP) to bind our hands against data mining. The intervention studied is a ‘‘community-driven development’’ program, which has become a popular strategy for foreign aid donors. We find positive short-run effects on local public goods and economic outcomes, but no evidence for sustained impacts on collective action, decision making, or the involvement of marginalized groups, suggesting that the intervention

Intervention

Two hundred thirty-six villages from two ethnically and politically distinct districts were randomly allocated into a treatment group or a comparison group. Villages in the treatment group were regularly visited by a GoBifo facilitator, who helped community members create or revamp Village Development Committees (VDCs), set up bank accounts for the VDCs, establish transparent budgeting practices, and create village development plans that included specifics on how GoBifo grants would be used. The participation and inclusion of marginalized groups was central to this process - for example, each social group (women, youth, and adult men) came up with their own development plan, and these plans were then combined into a single unified vision. Women were often established as treasurer of the VDC and served as co-signatories on all project finances. A series of block grants totaling US$4,667 per community were given to implement local public goods and skills training projects that were identified in the village development plans.

Household surveys, which covered participation in local decision-making, attitudes to minorities, and engagement in collective action, as well as demographic and socioeconomic information, were collected in late 2005 and again in mid-2009, along with village-level focus group discussions. In addition, three structured community activities (SCAs) were conducted in late 2009, shortly after GoBifo activities had ended, to capture any persistent impacts on collective action, participation of minorities, and elite capture. The SCAs were designed to measure how communities responded to concrete, real-world situations in three areas where GoBifo had sought to change behavior: (i) raising funds in response to a matching grant opportunity; (ii) making a community decision between two comparable alternatives; and (iii) allocating and managing an asset that was provided for free.

Experimental design

This analysis draws on three main data sources: household surveys from late 2005 (baseline) and mid-2009 (follow-up); village-level focus group discussions held in 2005 and 2009; and three novel SCAs conducted in late 2009 shortly after GoBifo activities had ended. The SCAs were introduced with the initial follow-up survey in May 2009 and then followed up in an unannounced visit five months later. The research team and enumerators were operationally separate from GoBifo staff at all stages of the project.

Design details

Randomization method
We ran 500 computer randomizations and saved all resulting assignments that generated no statistically significant differences (at 95% confidence) between treatment and control groups in terms of the total number of households per village and the distance to the nearest road. The randomization process for the island communities of Bonthe Town (which comprise 3.4 per cent of our sample) was conducted manually by a public lottery since there was no community list from the Statistics Sierra Leone (SSL) 2004 Population and Housing Census available for the town to use in the computerised process.
Randomization unit
Village level, stratifying on ward.
Clusters
236 villages
Observations
2,382 households
Arms
118 GoBifo treatment and 118 control villages
Primary outcomes
Project Implementation and Local Infrastructure Investment: The GoBifo project successfully established the village-level organizations and tools to manage development projects in nearly all cases. The distribution of project benefits within communities was equitable, leakage of project resources minimal, and minority participation high. GoBifo villages had a larger stock of higher quality local public goods, such as a functioning primary school or community grain-drying floor, than comparison areas. There was also more market activity in treatment communities, including the presence of more traders and items for sale, suggesting short-run economic gains. Institutional Change and Collective Action: There is no evidence that the program led to fundamental changes in local institutions or descision-making. Despite the fact that many women in treatment villages participated in GoBifo decisions, they were no more likely to voice an opinion in community meetings after the project ended or to play a leadership role in other areas. Similarly, the establishment of a democratically elected village development committee that carried out multiple projects did not lead treatment villages to be any more successful at raising funds in response to a later matching grant opportunity. Lastly, there were no program impacts on elite capture, although levels of capture were low in the research communities (at least as measured by the third SCA).

Materials

Papers from this trial

  1. Casey, Katherine, Rachel Glennerster, and Edward Miguel. 2012. "Reshaping Institutions: Evidence on Aid Impacts Using a Pre-Analysis Plan." Quarterly Journal of Economics 127(4): 1755-1812. http://www.povertyactionlab.org/publication/reshaping-institutions-evidence-aid-impacts-using-pre-analysis-plan
  2. Casey, Katherine, Rachel Glennerster, and Edward Miguel. "The GoBifo Project Evaluation Report: Assessing the Impacts of Community Driven Development in Sierra Leone." 3ie Impact Evaluation Report, October 2013. http://www.povertyactionlab.org/publication/gobifo-project-evaluation-report-assessing-impacts-community-driven-development-sierra-l

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords